Old Potrero Christmas Spirit Distilled From Beer is Back
A lot has changed since last year’s release of Old Potrero Christmas Spirit—most importantly, the San Francisco distillery that produced it, Hotaling & Co., closed its doors last February. But a few of the brands that were made there live on, including this whiskey distilled from Christmas Ale, which used to be produced by Anchor Brewing before that operation also shuttered. Here are the details of this latest limited-edition fan favorite release.
Hotaling was founded by Fritz Maytag in 1993 as Anchor Distilling Company. Maytag had previously made his name with Anchor Brewing, which produced the popular Anchor Steam among other beers. The brewery and distillery were acquired by Japanese company Sapporo in 2017, but the brewery closed a few years later in 2023. Chobani CEO and billionaire Hamdi Ulukaya purchased it in 2024, but didn’t seem to be doing much with the brand over the past few years. Last summer, however, KQED reported that the brewery had applied for and received approval for new beer labels for Anchor Steam and Old Foghorn, renewing hopes that these beloved beers will return.
Anchor Distilling, as it was known at the time, released its first rye whiskey, Old Potrero 18th Century, in 1996, the same year it launched its classic Junipero Gin. The distillery was renamed Hotaling & Co. in 2018 and continued to produce its own spirits as well as distribute spirits like Nikka Japanese whisky and Kavalan single malt from Taiwan. But last February we reported that the distillery was shutting down, just a couple of months after the 2025 Christmas Spirit release. At the time, a representative confirmed that both Junipero Gin and Old Potrero Rye would continue to be sold, and contract distilling would move to Corning & Co. in Rohnert Park, CA. We reached out to ask where the new Christmas Spirit was produced, but have not heard back yet.
In any case, like the 2025 edition, the 2026 release was distilled from San Francisco Christmas Spiced Ale and matured for a decade in once-used Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey barrels before being bottled at 100 proof (50 percent ABV). We did not get to sample this year’s release yet, but the official tasting notes describe aromas of citrus peel, maple syrup, and pine, with notes of cherry, malt, sweet orange peel, and spiced fruitcake on the palate. This is a very limited edition of just 492 bottles (SRP $140), and you can purchase it online or in liquor stores in California and Massachusetts now.
Authors
-
Jonah Flicker
Flicker is currently Robb Report’s whiskey critic, writing a weekly review of the most newsworthy releases around. He is a freelance writer covering the spirits industry whose work has appeared in…
