The Buffalo Trace Antique Collection Is Back With Another Upgrade
The last major whiskey release of the fall season, the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, has finally been unveiled. Last year marked a big change for the series with the addition of a sixth whiskey to the lineup, and this year there has been another upgrade to this unicorn collection of bourbon and rye. Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey is now bottled at a minimum of 12 years old, doubling the age at which this expression was previously bottled. I was able to taste the entire collection, so check out my thoughts and ranking below.
The Buffalo Trace Antique Collection, or BTAC as it’s commonly referred to by whiskey fans, was first released in 2000, shortly after the distillery was renamed Buffalo Trace. Initially, there were only three whiskeys in the lineup—Sazerac 18, Eagle Rare 17, and William Larue Weller 19. George T. Stagg was added a few years later, and in 2006 the lineup of two ryes and three bourbons was established—Sazerac 18, Eagle Rare 17, George T. Stagg, William Larue Weller, and Thomas H. Handy. Then last year a sixth whiskey was added, E.H. Taylor Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon, bringing the total lineup to six bottles.
As mentioned before, this year marks another big change to the collection. To celebrate the 20th anniversary of Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye, the age of the whiskey has been doubled to 12 years old—specifically, 12 years and six months old for this year’s release. “The Buffalo Trace Antique Collection has always been about honoring the people and brands that helped build this distillery while sharing whiskeys that reflect the patience and craftsmanship behind their production,” said master distiller Harlen Wheatley in a statement. “As we celebrate 20 years of Thomas H. Handy, we’re excited to mark an important milestone for the brand. Composing future releases from barrels aged a minimum of 12 years allows us to reveal a new dimension of the whiskey while preserving the bold rye character that has defined Thomas H. Handy since the beginning.”
At a press event earlier this week, I was able to sample all six whiskeys in the collection, so here is my ranking of this year’s lineup. I’m also including information about how much of the whiskey was lost to evaporation during maturation—the very high percentages are revealing as to just how intense aging in Kentucky warehouses can be.
6. William Larue Weller
The collection’s wheated bourbon member comes last in my ranking, as it usually does. This whiskey was aged for 12 years and seven months and bottled at 121.9 proof. Look for notes of fresh and dried orange, grass, lemon custard, butterscotch, and toasted pecans on the palate. 62 percent of this whiskey was lost to evaporation.
5. Thomas H. Handy Rye
Here’s the new and improved Handy, aged for a total of 12 years and six months and bottled at 130 proof. The extended maturation is definitely noticeable here—in a good way—as notes of rich cacao, cardamom, orange peel, and maple lead the palate, along with a healthy dose of black pepper and chili pepper. Just over 50 percent of the whiskey was lost during maturation.
4. Eagle Rare 17
This is the older version of Buffalo Trace’s core Eagle Rare bourbon, bottled at a higher 101 proof (as it was when it launched in 1975 as a direct competitor to Wild Turkey) after 17 years in barrels. This is another classic bourbon palate, with notes of grape candy, menthol, licorice, and butterscotch shell that end with a bit of sweet heat on the finish. 76 percent of the whiskey was lost during maturation.
3. Sazerac 18
My favorite whiskey of last year’s collection, Sazerac 18 came in third this year. This 18.5-year-old rye whiskey was bottled at 90 proof, and it’s a dusty, funky rye in the best sense of those words. Notes of spice and fruit complement gritty oak, black pepper, and some dried apricot flavors. If you want to get crazy, use this whiskey in a Manhattan, because I think it would hold up very well to sweet vermouth and bitters. 73 percent of the whiskey was lost during maturation.
2. E.H. Taylor Bottled-In-Bond Bourbon
The newest member of the collection came in second for me. This bourbon was also aged for 15 years, but bottled at a much lower 100 proof per bottled-in-bond regulations. This is just a classic well-aged bourbon, with notes of caramel, Cherry Coke, vanilla sundae, and maple candy on the palate, and only a flash of heat on the finish. This is a bourbon I could sip all day (although, to be clear, I do not advise doing that). Nearly 70 percent of the whiskey was lost to the angel’s share during its maturation.
1. George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
This is normally not my favorite in the collection, although many other people often rank it number one. However, this year really surprised me with just how good it was. It was aged for 15 years and bottled at 130.9 proof, which is actually relatively tame for this sometimes hazmat bourbon (and probably why I liked it so much). I picked up notes of coffee beans, caramel sundae with peanut topping, black pepper, and hot honey on the palate. According to the distillery, nearly 60 percent of the whiskey was lost to the angel’s share during its maturation.
The suggested retail price has gone up slightly for each bottle, from $150 to $155. While that information has to be included here, it’s also completely ludicrous because you will not find any of these bottles for less than several hundred dollars, often closer to $1,000, and an entire set often sells for around ten grand. That being said, the 2026 BTAC is available at select retailers around the country now, as well as at Sazerac’s Legacy de Forge website, so happy hunting and good luck.
Authors
-
Jonah Flicker
Flicker is currently Robb Report’s whiskey critic, writing a weekly review of the most newsworthy releases around. He is a freelance writer covering the spirits industry whose work has appeared in…
